Have you ever wondered why marketers always seem to be beating you over the head with new buzzwords, sometimes even for products that you can’t even buy yet? I think I may have stumbled upon something that helps explain why.

I was doing my usual trolling on LinkedIn and I saw a post that talked about something called the Gartner Hype Cycle and it actually made me think about some of the biggest disconnects between tech marketers and the actual IT pros that I’ve talked to. The idea behind the Hype Cycle is to illustrate the typical pattern that happens whenever new technologies start to come to market and how they get adopted by buyers.

Here’s an example of the hype cycle of 2018, so you can get a picture of what people thought was the “next big thing” back then, and where they actually all landed 6 years later:

I think one of the main disconnects between tech marketers (and the media they consume) and where IT pros actually prefer to sit in the buying cycle, as my nifty illustration at the top shows.

I think a lot of folks, both marketers and just non-IT normies alike, think IT pros are tech heads that are always buying the hottest new gadgets on the street before the rest of the world can get their hands on them. In reality though, I think IT pros as an industry are incentivized to be as risk-averse as possible. In other words, they get paid to keep the lights on, not be the coolest kid on the block.

Moreover, because many IT pros aren’t being brought into early business strategy planning, they don’t even have the opportunity to provide input on new technologies that could potentially provide a competitive advantage for their companies, even if they felt like there was one. Not to mention how many IT pros have been burned by something new being brought into their environment that ended up jeopardizing everything else that already works.

As a result, while marketers think IT pros want to be looped in during the Peak of Inflated Expectations, I think most IT pros actually prefer to be well out of the Trough of Disillusionment and well onto the Slope of Enlightenment before they really feel comfortable enough exploring new technologies as an option.

(Side note: why do these all sound like Harry Potter/LOTR/Princess Bride locations?)

38f614b6-5eed-40f5-b67b-ff8d93a52fc0_text

What do y’all think? Do you agree with this take? Where on the map do you actually like to start researching technologies? What would make you want to explore something potentially earlier? And what do you actually want to know about overhyped technologies that are still on that first upward curve? (Anything at all?)

19 Spice ups

That first image is brill and spot-on.

8 Spice ups

IT Pro Gandalf, probably: “Good IT pros are not always early adopters, nor are they late. They keep the system running precisely when it’s needed.”

13 Spice ups

I think a lot of the disparity between marketing and IT is that marketing doesn’t (iMHO) doesn’t know anything about the product being hyped other than the hype. IT has to repeatedly tell both user and management the reality of what can actually occur and (more importantly) what it can’t. That is what actually drives the concept/product into the Trough of Disillusionment and what causes these concepts/products into the Desert of Ignominy. Look at AI as the current example. All the rah-rah hoopty doo is already sliding into the Trough…

7 Spice ups

That is beautiful.

pexels-photo-48840s

7 Spice ups

THIS - I keep an eye on new technologies and try them out if & when I can but only adopt them when they meet an actual need in the company (or my life). In my personal life, too: I don’t even have a smart TV. The iPad I have is one the company was done with (still runs Kindle). I use an Android phone I could afford. I’ve used ChatGPT twice to figure out some complex Excel formulas. I didn’t adopt Windows XP until I couldn’t get Win 2K on new computers anymore (same for 7 & 10, never used 8). There are some IT hipsters out there, and I don’t think you’ll find many of them here.

What really bugs me is when we ask a company if their tech can help us do what we want (being quite specific) and their sales people say “Yes!” Then we get the tech, it doesn’t meet expectations, and the support people ask, “Who told you it would do that?” :face_with_raised_eyebrow: Or the company (same one) advertises “Use this great new feature!” We upgrade to use it, find it hasn’t been fleshed out, and other features don’t work right anymore! :rage: (This is what keeps my meditation/yoga practice strong) :man_kneeling:

5 Spice ups

Sounds like @Jeff-Grettler-Spiceworks should bring back “Yoga for IT Pros”

Also, this:

11 Spice ups

Hammer for me, goverment don’t allow us to have guns

4 Spice ups

There’s an old term “heat seekers” for people who have to have the latest and greatest. I don’t see many of those people in IT. Some are people I know do get into things like home automation but more as tinkerers building their rather than buying the latest shiny thing.
A lot are techno skeptics who avoid connected devices etc. at home because they don’t trust it. Personally I’m a cheapskate who avoids spending on tech and enjoys older stuff. My stereo is from Goodwill and garage sales and sits in a cabinet I bought off Facebook. My PC is an off-lease ThinkPad from eBay and apart from photography my hobbies are analog.

2 Spice ups

Like many here, I find myself slow to adopt tech for home use. I have no IoT devices, and my TV is smart but only because it just happens to be - I couldn’t find one in my size and price range that wasn’t - had never used any of the smart features. Until my last move a few months ago when I was shocked to learn that cable was not available at my new address and never would be despite surrounding properties having cable service. I was stumped as to what to do about internet access and TV and decided to try wireless - which I was always sort of skeptical about - and went with T-Mobile 5G. I was pleasantly surprised that a) I was in the coverage area, and b) the down and up speeds I get are well in excess of the advertised speeds. I then activated the smart TV features and have been glad I coincidentally purchased the capability.

I guess that makes me a reluctant adopter.

1 Spice up

My partner and I have a bunch of Echoes around the house, and lights that we control from them, but that’s as far as it goes (at least until I wire up the thermostat). We’ve thought about cameras and doorbells and security and so on, but it just doesn’t appeal. It’s useful to be able to play music in whichever room we’re in without it being somewhat tinny from a phone (for some reason, Clutch is really good for cooking to), turn lights on when your hands are full, or to announce things to the house without having to shout or go and find everyone.
Yes, GCHQ may be able to hear what I’m saying, but I live close enough that if I shout they’ll probably hear anyway. :slight_smile: